Law / United States /
California
California public nuisance (abatement by a public body or officer)
Cal. Civ. Code §§ 3479, 3480, 3482, 3491, 3493, 3494; Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 731
In force.
A public nuisance rule binding private bodies.
What it requires
- Keep AI models you develop, train or test from accessing external computer systems without authorization; California's Attorney General alleged on that developing, training and testing models without sufficient cybersecurity safeguards created a public nuisance (complaint, San Francisco Superior Court, paras. 103 to 109).
- Expect a public officer's suit over a public nuisance to seek abatement; a civil action in the name of the people under Code of Civil Procedure section 731 is brought to abate, and abatement is one of the remedies Civil Code section 3491 lists.
- Check whether a statute expressly authorizes the conduct before treating it as exposed; nothing done or maintained under the express authority of a statute can be deemed a nuisance (Civil Code section 3482).
- Expect the suit to come from a public body or officer authorized by law (Civil Code section 3494); a private person may sue over a public nuisance only if it is specially injurious to that person (section 3493).
- Treat maintaining a public nuisance as possibly criminal as well as civil; maintaining or committing one, where no other punishment is prescribed, is a misdemeanor (Penal Code section 372).
These lines are LexLint's reading of the law's text.
If you get it wrong
Criminal exposureYes
Private right of actionYes
Criminal exposure note
Penal Code section 372 makes maintaining or committing a public nuisance, where no other punishment is prescribed, a misdemeanor, and section 370 defines a public nuisance in the Penal Code.
Who enforces it
Enforcement body
The district attorney or county counsel of a county in which the nuisance exists, or the city attorney of a town or city in which it exists, in a civil action in the name of the people of the State of California to abate a public nuisance (Code of Civil Procedure section 731).
Settledness
- As of
- Open questions
- Do Civil Code sections 3479 and 3480 reach a developer's development, training or testing of artificial intelligence or other software as a public nuisance?
What this law does
California's public-nuisance statutes treat as a nuisance anything injurious to health, indecent or offensive to the senses, or an obstruction to the free use of property, so as to interfere with the comfortable enjoyment of life or property (Civil Code section 3479), and a nuisance is public when it affects at the same time an entire community or neighborhood, or any considerable number of persons (section 3480).
On California's Attorney General sued OpenAI in San Francisco Superior Court, alleging that developing, training and testing its AI models without sufficient cybersecurity safeguards created a public nuisance. On that count the complaint asks for an order requiring OpenAI to abate the nuisance. That is an allegation, and no court has ruled on whether these statutes reach the development, training or testing of software.
The remedies against a public nuisance are indictment or information, a civil action, or abatement (section 3491). A public body or officer authorized by law may abate a public nuisance (section 3494), and a district attorney, county counsel or city attorney may sue in the name of the people to abate one (Code of Civil Procedure section 731). The complaint pleads that the Attorney General is such an officer (paragraph 102). A private person may sue over a public nuisance only if it is specially injurious to that person (section 3493).
Section 731 also lets a person whose property is injuriously affected, or whose personal enjoyment is lessened, by a nuisance as defined in section 3479 sue to enjoin or abate it and recover damages. Nothing done or maintained under the express authority of a statute can be deemed a nuisance (section 3482), and maintaining or committing a public nuisance with no other punishment prescribed is a misdemeanor (Penal Code section 372).
Sections 3482, 3493 and 3494 were enacted in 1872, while the history notes for sections 3479, 3480 and 3491 record only their latest amendments, so the sections state no single day on which the regime as a whole came into force. Section 3480 was last amended effective (Statutes of 2025, chapter 67, AB 1170).
When LexLint raises it
When your app profile says your app is a frontier developer.
Back to the example · Lint your app
Page updated .
us-ca-cal-civ-3479-3480-3482-3491-3493-3494-cal