Law of 8 March 2023 on the accessibility requirements applicable to products and services, duties of providers of electronic communications, audiovisual access, transport, consumer banking, e-book and e-commerce services
Loi du 8 mars 2023 (art. 1er, paragraphes 2, 4 et 5, art. 6, paragraphes 1er et 3 à 7, art. 15 à 17, art. 25, art. 28 à 30, art. 32 à 35 et annexe II) relative aux exigences en matière d’accessibilité applicables aux produits et services
In force since .
An accessibility requirements rule binding public and private bodies.
What it requires
- If you provide electronic communications services (other than machine-to-machine transmission), services providing access to audiovisual media services, consumer banking services, e-books and dedicated software, or e-commerce services, design and provide them to meet the accessibility requirements of Annex I, Section III, and Section IV, of Directive (EU) 2019/882 (Art. 1(2), 6(1) and 6(3); implements Directive Art. 4(1) and (3)).
- If you provide air, rail, inland waterway or bus passenger transport services, design and provide their websites, mobile device-based services including mobile applications, electronic tickets and ticketing services, transport service information and interactive self-service terminals in the Union to meet Annex I, Sections III and IV, of the Directive; for urban, suburban and regional transport services only the interactive self-service terminals are covered, and Art. 6(3) excepts those services from Section III (Art. 1(2), point 3°, as amended by the Law of , and Art. 6(3)).
- If you are a microenterprise providing services, the accessibility requirements of Art. 6(3) and the obligations relating to compliance with them do not apply to you; a microenterprise is an enterprise that employs fewer than ten persons and has an annual turnover not exceeding EUR 2,000,000 or an annual balance sheet total not exceeding EUR 2,000,000 (Art. 6(4) and Art. 2, point 14°; implements Directive Art. 4(5)).
- Prepare the information of Annex II explaining how your service meets the applicable accessibility requirements, include it in your general terms and conditions or an equivalent document, make it available to the public in written and oral form, including in a manner accessible to persons with disabilities, and keep it for as long as the service is available (Art. 15(2) and Annex II; implements Directive Art. 13(2)).
- Keep procedures in place so that the provision of your services remains in conformity, taking adequate account of changes in the characteristics of the service, in the accessibility requirements and in the harmonised standards or technical specifications by reference to which conformity is declared (Art. 15(3); implements Directive Art. 13(3)).
- If a service is not in conformity, take the corrective measures needed to bring it into conformity, inform OSAPS immediately with details of the non-conformity and the corrective measures, supply on OSAPS’s reasoned request all the information needed to show conformity, and cooperate with OSAPS (Art. 15(4)-(5); implements Directive Art. 13(4) and (5)).
- You may rely on the limits of Art. 16(1), that compliance not require a significant modification that fundamentally alters the service or impose a disproportionate burden, only after assessing them on the criteria of Annex VI to the Directive, supporting the assessment with evidence, keeping all relevant results for five years from the date the service was last provided, giving OSAPS a copy of the assessment on request, and informing the authorities responsible for checking the conformity of services of the Member State where the service is provided (Art. 16(1)-(3) and (7); implements Directive Art. 14).
- If you rely on the disproportionate-burden limit, renew the assessment for each category or type of service when the service you offer is modified, when OSAPS asks, and in any event at least every five years; you cannot rely on the limit for a service for which you receive funding for improving accessibility from sources other than your own resources, public or private (Art. 16(5)-(6)).
- Until you may keep providing your services using products you lawfully used to provide similar services before that date; service contracts agreed before the Law’s entry into force on may run unchanged until they expire but for no more than five years from that date; self-service terminals you lawfully used to provide services before the Law’s entry into force may stay in use for similar services until the end of their economically useful life, which may not exceed twenty years after they were put into service (Art. 34(2)-(3) and 36; implements Directive Art. 32).
- Do not obstruct the officials of OSAPS or the Grand-Ducal Police when they enter premises, test devices, request books, registers and files, take samples or seize products used to provide the service, and comply with the decisions OSAPS addresses to you, including a prohibition or restriction of the service, a temporary ban, a prohibition on providing a service that misleads or risks misleading on its real characteristics, and a recall, a withdrawal, a modification or a destruction of the product used (Art. 25(3), 28(1), point 4°, 28(2) and (3), 29, 30).
These lines are LexLint's reading of the law's text.
If you get it wrong
Criminal exposureYes
Criminal exposure note
Article 33(1) of the Law punishes a breach of Article 6(1), (2), (3), (5), (6) or (7) or of Articles 9, 11, 12, 13 or 15 with a fine of EUR 251 to EUR 500,000, and Article 33(2) punishes a repeat offender with a fine of EUR 500 to EUR 1,000,000; under Article 36 of the Criminal Code the maximum for a legal person is double, EUR 1,000,000 and EUR 2,000,000.
Penalty structure
Article 33(1) punishes a breach of Article 6(1), (2), (3), (5), (6) or (7) or of Articles 9, 11, 12, 13 or 15 with a fine of EUR 251 to EUR 500,000, proportioned to the extent and seriousness of the non-conformity, the number of non-conforming units or services and the number of persons concerned, and Article 33(2) sets a fine of EUR 500 to EUR 1,000,000 for a repeat offender. Article 33(1) excepts the cases of Article 6(4), the microenterprise exemption, and Article 16(1). Article 36 of the Criminal Code doubles the maximum correctional fine for a legal person and sets its minimum at EUR 500, so a legal person faces up to EUR 1,000,000 under Article 33(1) and up to EUR 2,000,000 as a repeat offender under Article 33(2). Article 32(1) and (2) let OSAPS fine an economic operator EUR 250 to EUR 15,000 for refusing documents or information, obstructing the surveillance, or not complying with its decisions under Article 24(2) or Article 25(3); the fine is payable within thirty days of notification (Article 32(3)). Article 33(4) lets the courts order confiscation and destruction of the goods used for the offence and confiscation of illicit profits. The ceiling coded is the maximum for a legal person that is a repeat offender, and the minimum is the lowest fine of Article 33(1), which applies to a natural person.
- Rule
- Fixed only
- As of
- Minimum
- 251
- Currency
- EUR
- Fixed cap
- 2,000,000
Who enforces it
Enforcement body
The Office de la surveillance de l’accessibilité des produits et services (OSAPS), with the Grand-Ducal Police, which Article 28(2) charges, with OSAPS, with checking the conformity of services in collaboration with the authorities responsible for the services concerned
What it reaches
Instrument type
an act of a legislature
Applicability criteria
Article 6(4) exempts a microenterprise providing services from the requirements of Article 6(3) and from all obligations relating to compliance with them; Article 2, point 14°, defines a microenterprise as « une entreprise qui emploie moins de dix personnes et dont le chiffre d’affaires annuel n’excède pas 2 000 000 euros ou dont le total du bilan annuel n’excède pas 2 000 000 euros » (an enterprise that employs fewer than ten persons and whose annual turnover does not exceed EUR 2,000,000 or whose annual balance sheet total does not exceed EUR 2,000,000), the Directive’s own disjunction.
- As of
- Combinator
- Any of
- Criteria
- a provider of electronic communications services, with the exception of transmission services used for the provision of machine-to-machine services (Article 1(2), point 1°)
- a provider of services providing access to audiovisual media services (Article 1(2), point 2°)
- a provider of the websites, mobile device-based services, electronic tickets and ticketing services, transport service information and interactive self-service terminals of air, rail, inland waterway and bus passenger transport services, with only the interactive self-service terminals covered for urban, suburban and regional transport services (Article 1(2), point 3°, as amended)
- a provider of consumer banking services (Article 1(2), point 4°, and Article 2, point 29°)
- a provider of e-books and dedicated software (Article 1(2), point 5°)
- a provider of e-commerce services (Article 1(2), point 6°, and Article 2, point 31°)
What this law does
Article 1(2), points 1° and 2°, of the Law of covers electronic communications services, other than transmission services used for machine-to-machine services, and services providing access to audiovisual media services.
Article 1(2), point 3°, covers the elements of air, rail, inland waterway and bus passenger transport services that are websites, mobile device-based services including mobile applications, electronic tickets and ticketing services, delivery of transport service information, and interactive self-service terminals located in the Union. Article 1(2), point 3°, as amended by the Law of , excludes urban, suburban and regional transport services.
Article 1(2), point 3°, provides that for urban, suburban and regional transport services only the interactive self-service terminals of point e) apply. Article 2 of the Law of provides that it enters into force on . Article 1(2), points 4° to 6°, covers consumer banking services, e-books and dedicated software, and e-commerce.
Article 2, point 29°, defines consumer banking services as the provision to consumers of consumer credit contracts and mortgage credit contracts under the Consumer Code, electronic money, payment services, the services of points 1, 2, 4 and 5 of Sections A and C of Annex II to the amended Law of on the financial sector, and services linked to payment accounts.
Article 2, point 31°, defines e-commerce services as services provided at a distance, through websites and mobile device-based services, by electronic means and at the individual request of a consumer, with a view to concluding a consumer contract.
Article 2, point 40°, defines services providing access to audiovisual media services to include the electronic programme guides and the accessibility elements, such as subtitling for deaf or hard of hearing people, audio description, spoken subtitles and sign language interpretation, resulting from the measures of Article 27quater of the amended Law of on electronic media.
Article 1(4) of the Law covers, among the contents of websites and mobile applications, published pre-recorded time-based media and published office file formats.
Article 2(4), points (a) and (b), of the Directive excludes from its scope pre-recorded time-based media and office file formats published before ; Article 1(4) of the Law lists published pre-recorded time-based media and published office file formats without that date, and Article 34(1) applies the Law to the contents of Article 1(4) that are provided to consumers after its entry into force.
Article 1(5) of the Law does not apply to online maps and mapping services where the essential information for maps used for navigation is provided in an accessible digital form, to third-party content that the operator neither funds, develops nor controls, or to archive content that is not updated or modified after the Law’s entry into force.
Article 1(6) of the Law is without prejudice to Article 10ter of the amended Law of on copyright and related rights and to Regulation (EU) 2017/1563 on the cross-border exchange of accessible-format copies of certain works. Article 6(3) of the Law requires all services other than urban, suburban and regional transport services to meet the requirements of Annex I, Section III, to the Directive, and all services to meet those of Section IV.
Article 4(3) of the Directive, which Article 6(3) of the Law implements, sets the same two sections for services. Article 6(4) of the Law exempts microenterprises that provide services from the accessibility requirements of paragraph 3 and from all obligations relating to compliance with them. Article 6(5) of the Law has OSAPS provide guidelines and tools to microenterprises, developed in consultation with the authorities responsible for the products and services concerned.
Article 7 of the Law deems services that meet the accessible-information requirements of the EU passenger rights regulations to conform to the corresponding requirements of the Law, and applies in full any additional requirement the Law sets.
Article 15 of the Law requires a service provider to design and provide services in accordance with the accessibility requirements and to prepare the information of Annex II explaining how the services meet them, made available to the public in written and oral form, including in a manner accessible to persons with disabilities, and kept as long as the service is available.
Article 15(3) of the Law requires a service provider to keep procedures in place so that the provision of services remains in conformity, taking account of changes in the characteristics of the service, in the requirements and in the harmonised standards or technical specifications relied on.
Article 15(4) and (5) of the Law require a service provider whose service is not in conformity to take the necessary corrective measures, to inform OSAPS immediately with details of the non-conformity and the corrective measures, to supply on reasoned request the information needed to show conformity, and to cooperate with OSAPS.
Article 13 of the Directive, which Article 15 of the Law implements, requires service providers to design and provide services in accordance with the accessibility requirements and to prepare the Annex V information.
Annex II to the Law requires the provider to include the information assessing how the service meets the accessibility requirements in its general terms and conditions or an equivalent document, containing a general description of the service in accessible formats, the descriptions needed to understand its operation, and a description of how the requirements of Annex I to the Directive are met.
Article 16(1) of the Law applies the accessibility requirements only to the extent that compliance does not require a significant modification that fundamentally alters the nature of the product or service and does not impose a disproportionate burden on the economic operators concerned.
Article 16(3) of the Law requires economic operators to supply evidence for the assessment of Article 16(2), to keep the results for five years from the date a service was last provided, and to give OSAPS a copy of the assessment on request.
Article 16(5) of the Law requires a service provider that relies on the disproportionate-burden limit to renew the assessment for each category or type of service when the service offered is modified, at the request of OSAPS, and in any event at least every five years. Article 16(6) of the Law bars an economic operator from relying on the disproportionate-burden limit when it receives funding from sources other than its own resources, public or private, for improving accessibility.
Article 16(7) of the Law requires an operator that relies on paragraph 1 for a specific service to inform the authorities responsible for checking the conformity of services of the Member State where the service is provided, and excludes microenterprises from that duty.
Article 17(1) of the Law presumes products and services that conform to harmonised standards, or parts of them, whose references are published in the Official Journal of the European Union to conform to the accessibility requirements to the extent those standards cover them.
Article 25 of the Law has OSAPS, with the authorities responsible for the services concerned, establish and apply procedures to verify the conformity of services including the Article 16 assessment, to follow up complaints, and to verify that the operator has taken the corrective measures needed.
Article 25(1), point 1°, of the Law applies Article 21(2) mutatis mutandis to the verification of a service provider’s Article 16 assessment, under which OSAPS checks that the assessment was carried out, examines it and its results, including the correct use of the criteria of Annex VI to the Directive, and checks conformity with the accessibility requirements. Article 25(2) of the Law lets any natural or legal person report the non-conformity of a service to OSAPS.
Article 25(3) of the Law has OSAPS, where the operator has not taken the necessary corrective measures and the non-conformity persists, inform the competent entity without delay and decide all appropriate measures to restrict or prohibit the provision of the service.
Article 28(2) of the Law lets OSAPS, after checks on services, prohibit or restrict the provision of a non-conforming service, ban it temporarily during the checks, and order or organise the recall, withdrawal, modification and destruction of the product used to provide a non-conforming service. Article 28(1), point 4°, of the Law lets OSAPS prohibit offering for sale a product or providing a service that misleads or risks misleading on its real characteristics.
Article 28(5) of the Law makes the decisions of OSAPS under paragraphs 1 and 2 subject to an appeal for reformation before the administrative tribunal within three months of notification. Article 29 of the Law has the offences established by OSAPS officials of salary categories A and B and by agents of the Customs and Excise Administration from the grade of brigadier principal, who have the status of judicial police officers in the exercise of those functions.
Article 32(1) of the Law lets OSAPS fine an economic operator EUR 250 to EUR 15,000 for refusing to supply documents or information requested in the checking of the conformity of services, or for obstructing that checking. Article 32(2) of the Law lets OSAPS fine an economic operator EUR 250 to EUR 15,000 for not complying with its decisions under Article 24(2) and Article 25(3).
Article 32(3) of the Law makes the administrative fines payable within thirty days of notification of the written decision, notwithstanding an appeal, and opens an appeal for reformation before the administrative tribunal within three months of notification; Article 32(4) entrusts their recovery to the Administration de l’enregistrement, des domaines et de la TVA (Registration Duties, Estates and VAT Authority).
Article 33(1) of the Law punishes an economic operator that contravenes Article 6(1), (2), (3), (5), (6) or (7) or Articles 9, 11, 12, 13 or 15 with a fine of EUR 251 to EUR 500,000, except in the cases of Article 6(4) and Article 16(1). Article 33(2) of the Law punishes an operator already sentenced to a fine under paragraph 1 with a fine of EUR 500 to EUR 1,000,000 as a repeat offender.
Article 33(3) of the Law counts final convictions in other Member States towards repeat offending where the offences are also punishable under Directive (EU) 2019/882 as transposed there. Article 33(4) of the Law lets the courts order the confiscation and destruction of the goods used for the offence and the confiscation of illicit profits.
Article 16 of the Criminal Code sets the fine in correctional matters at EUR 251 at least, the floor of Article 33(1), and Article 36 of the Criminal Code provides that the fine for a legal person in correctional matters is at least EUR 500 and that its maximum is double the maximum the law punishing the offence sets for natural persons, so EUR 1,000,000 for a legal person under Article 33(1) and EUR 2,000,000 for a legal person that is a repeat offender under Article 33(2).
Article 34(1) of the Law applies it to the services of Article 1(2) that are provided to consumers after its entry into force. Article 34(2) of the Law lets service providers keep providing their services until using products they lawfully used for similar services before that date, and lets service contracts agreed before the Law’s entry into force run unchanged until they expire, but for no more than five years from that date.
Article 34(3) of the Law lets self-service terminals that service providers lawfully used before the Law’s entry into force continue to be used for similar services until the end of their economically useful life, which may not exceed twenty years after they were put into service. Article 32 of the Directive makes the transitional period mandatory for Member States and leaves the self-service terminal option to them.
Article 35(1) of the Law applies amendments to Annexes I and VI of the Directive from the day the corresponding European Union acts enter into force. Article 35(2) of the Law requires the minister to publish a notice in the Journal officiel of the amendments that have taken effect, with a reference to the act published in the Official Journal of the European Union.
When LexLint raises it
When your app profile says your app ships a consumer interface, ships a mobile app, distributes a software product, provides telecom services or provides financial services.
Back to the example · Lint your app
Page updated .