Law / European Union

Platform Work Directive, Transparency, Human Oversight and Human Review of Automated Systems (Articles 9 to 11)

Directive (EU) 2024/2831, Arts. 9-11

A data subject rights rule binding public and private bodies.

Obligation class
Data subject rights, Disclosure, Governance

As of .

What it requires

  • This duty takes effect on , the date by which Member States must bring into force the laws, regulations and administrative provisions necessary to comply with the Directive (Article 29(1)).
  • This Directive is addressed to the Member States (Article 32), which must bring into force the laws, regulations and administrative provisions necessary to comply with it by (Article 29(1)), so a digital labour platform meets these rules through each Member State's transposing law.
  • If you are a digital labour platform, inform persons performing platform work, platform workers' representatives and, upon request, national competent authorities of the use of automated monitoring systems or automated decision-making systems (Article 9(1)).
  • Include in that information, for an automated monitoring system, the fact that it is in use or is in the process of being introduced, the categories of data and action monitored, supervised or evaluated, including evaluation by the recipient of the service, the aim of the monitoring and how the system carries it out, and the recipients or categories of recipient of the personal data processed and any transmission or transfer of it, including within a group of undertakings (Article 9(1), point (a)).
  • Include in that information, for an automated decision-making system, the fact that it is in use or is in the process of being introduced, the categories of decision it takes or supports, the categories of data and the main parameters it takes into account and their relative importance, including the way the personal data or behaviour of the person performing platform work influence the decisions, and the grounds for decisions to restrict, suspend or terminate the account of the person performing platform work, to refuse the payment for work performed by them, as well as decisions on their contractual status or any decision of equivalent or detrimental effect (Article 9(1), point (b)), together with all categories of decision taken or supported by automated systems that affect persons performing platform work in any manner (Article 9(1), point (c)).
  • Provide the information as a written document, which may be in electronic form, in a transparent, intelligible and easily accessible form, using clear and plain language (Article 9(2)).
  • Provide a person performing platform work, in a concise form, the information about the systems and their features that directly affect them, including where applicable their working conditions, at the latest on the first working day, prior to the introduction of changes affecting working conditions, the organisation of work or monitoring work performance, and at any time upon their request; on their request, also provide it in a comprehensive and detailed form for all relevant systems and their features (Article 9(3)).
  • Provide workers' representatives, in a comprehensive and detailed form, the information about all relevant systems and their features prior to the use of those systems, prior to the introduction of changes affecting working conditions, the organisation of work or monitoring work performance, and at any time upon their request, and provide national competent authorities the same information in a comprehensive and detailed form at any time upon their request (Article 9(4)).
  • Provide a person undergoing a recruitment or selection procedure, before the start of the procedure, concise information concerning only the automated monitoring systems or automated decision-making systems used in that procedure (Article 9(5)).
  • Honor a person performing platform work's right to the portability of personal data generated through their performance of work in the context of your automated monitoring systems or automated decision-making systems, including ratings and reviews: provide them, free of charge, with tools to facilitate the effective exercise of that right and of their portability rights under Article 20 of Regulation (EU) 2016/679, and, where the person so requests, transmit the data directly to a third party (Article 9(6)).
  • Oversee, and with the involvement of workers' representatives, regularly and in any event every two years, evaluate the impact of individual decisions taken or supported by automated monitoring systems and automated decision-making systems on persons performing platform work, including, where applicable, on their working conditions and equal treatment at work (Article 10(1)).
  • Ensure sufficient human resources for the effective oversight and evaluation of the impact of those decisions, and give the persons charged with that function the competence, training and authority necessary to exercise it, including for overriding automated decisions (Article 10(2)).
  • Where the oversight or evaluation identifies a high risk of discrimination at work in the use of your automated monitoring systems or automated decision-making systems, or finds that individual decisions have infringed the rights of a person performing platform work, take the steps necessary, including, if appropriate, the modification of the system or the discontinuation of its use, in order to avoid such decisions in the future (Article 10(3)).
  • Transmit information on the evaluation to platform workers' representatives, and make it available to persons performing platform work and to national competent authorities upon their request (Article 10(4)).
  • Have any decision to restrict, suspend or terminate the contractual relationship or the account of a person performing platform work, or any other decision of equivalent detriment, taken by a human being (Article 10(5)).
  • A person performing platform work has the right to obtain an oral or written explanation from you for any decision taken or supported by an automated decision-making system without undue delay, provided in a transparent and intelligible manner, using clear and plain language (Article 11(1)).
  • Give persons performing platform work access to a contact person you designate to discuss and clarify the facts, circumstances and reasons that led to such a decision, and ensure the contact person has the competence, training and authority necessary to exercise that function (Article 11(1)).
  • Provide the person performing platform work with a written statement of the reasons for any decision taken or supported by an automated decision-making system to restrict, suspend or terminate their account, to refuse the payment for work performed by them, on their contractual status, with similar effects, or otherwise affecting the essential aspects of the employment or other contractual relationships, without undue delay and at the latest on the date on which it takes effect (Article 11(1)).
  • On the request of a person performing platform work, or of their representative acting on their behalf in accordance with national law or practice, review a decision referred to in Article 11(1), and respond with a sufficiently precise and adequately substantiated reply in the form of a written document, which may be in electronic form, without undue delay and in any event within two weeks of receipt of the request (Article 11(2)).
  • Where a decision referred to in Article 11(1) infringes the rights of a person performing platform work, rectify it without delay and in any case within two weeks of its adoption; where rectification is not possible, offer adequate compensation for the damage sustained; and in any event take the steps necessary, including, if appropriate, the modification of the automated decision-making system or the discontinuation of its use, in order to avoid such decisions in the future (Article 11(3)).

If you get it wrong

Penalty structure

Article 24(1), second sentence, of Directive (EU) 2024/2831 makes the upper limit for administrative fines referred to in Article 83(5) of Regulation (EU) 2016/679 applicable to infringements of Articles 7 to 11 of the Directive, which is EUR 20,000,000 or, for an undertaking, 4 percent of total worldwide annual turnover of the preceding financial year, whichever is higher, imposed by the supervisory authorities responsible for that Regulation (Article 24(1), first sentence). The Directive does not print the amount, so the pin sits on Article 83(5) of Regulation (EU) 2016/679. The fine is coded for Articles 9 to 11 only; Article 24(5) leaves the penalties for other national provisions to the Member States.

Rule
Higher of
As of
Currency
EUR
Fixed cap
20,000,000
Turnover percentage cap
4

Who enforces it

Enforcement body

The supervisory authority or authorities responsible for monitoring the application of Regulation (EU) 2016/679, which are also responsible for monitoring and enforcing Articles 7 to 11 of the Directive as far as data-protection matters are concerned (Article 24(1)); those authorities and the other national competent authorities cooperate in the enforcement of the Directive (Article 24(2)).

What this law does

Drafted with AI

Drafted with AI from the cited sources under the direction of UnGovr staff. UnGovr holds editorial responsibility for this page. How this site is made

Research summary

Legal information, not legal advice. This is LexLint's own research summary of a public legal source, and it creates no attorney-client relationship. For decisions that matter, consult qualified counsel in the relevant jurisdiction. About LexLint

Article 9(1) requires Member States to require digital labour platforms to inform persons performing platform work, platform workers' representatives and, upon request, national competent authorities, of the use of automated monitoring systems or automated decision-making systems.

For automated monitoring systems, Article 9(1), point (a), covers the fact that such systems are in use or are in the process of being introduced, the categories of data and action monitored, supervised or evaluated, the aim of the monitoring and how the system is to carry it out, and the recipients or categories of recipient of the personal data processed and any transmission or transfer of it, including within a group of undertakings.

For automated decision-making systems, Article 9(1), point (b), covers the fact that such systems are in use or are in the process of being introduced, the categories of decision taken or supported, the categories of data and the main parameters that such systems take into account and their relative importance, including the way the personal data or behaviour of the person performing platform work influence the decisions, and the grounds for decisions to restrict, suspend or terminate the account of the person performing platform work, to refuse the payment for work performed by them, as well as decisions on their contractual status or any decision of equivalent or detrimental effect.

Article 9(1), point (c), adds all categories of decision taken or supported by automated systems that affect persons performing platform work in any manner. Article 9(2) requires the information in the form of a written document, which may be in electronic form, presented in a transparent, intelligible and easily accessible form, using clear and plain language.

Article 9(3) requires digital labour platforms to give persons performing platform work, in a concise form, the information about the systems and their features that directly affect them, at the latest on the first working day, prior to the introduction of changes affecting working conditions, the organisation of work or monitoring work performance, and at any time upon their request.

Article 9(4) requires digital labour platforms to give workers' representatives, in a comprehensive and detailed form, the information about all relevant systems and their features prior to the use of those systems, prior to the introduction of changes affecting working conditions, the organisation of work or monitoring work performance, and at any time upon their request, and to give national competent authorities the same information at any time upon their request.

Article 9(5) requires digital labour platforms to give persons undergoing a recruitment or selection procedure concise information, concerning only the systems used in that procedure, before the start of the procedure.

Article 9(6) gives persons performing platform work the right to the portability of personal data generated through their performance of work in the context of a digital labour platform's automated monitoring systems or automated decision-making systems, including ratings and reviews, and requires the platform to provide free tools to exercise it and, on request, to transmit the data directly to a third party.

Article 10(1) requires Member States to ensure that digital labour platforms oversee and, with the involvement of workers' representatives, regularly and in any event every two years, evaluate the impact of individual decisions taken or supported by automated monitoring systems and automated decision-making systems on persons performing platform work.

Article 10(2) requires Member States to require digital labour platforms to ensure sufficient human resources for the effective oversight and evaluation of those decisions, with persons charged with that function who have the competence, training and authority necessary, including for overriding automated decisions.

Article 10(5) provides that any decision to restrict, suspend or terminate the contractual relationship or the account of a person performing platform work, or any other decision of equivalent detriment, shall be taken by a human being. Article 11(1) provides that persons performing platform work have the right to obtain an oral or written explanation from the digital labour platform for any decision taken or supported by an automated decision-making system without undue delay.

Article 11(2) gives persons performing platform work the right to request the digital labour platform to review the decisions referred to in Article 11(1), and requires a sufficiently precise and adequately substantiated written reply without undue delay and in any event within two weeks of receipt of the request.

Article 11(3) requires the digital labour platform, where such a decision infringes the rights of a person performing platform work, to rectify it without delay and in any case within two weeks of its adoption, or, where rectification is not possible, to offer adequate compensation for the damage sustained. Article 11(5) provides that Article 11 does not apply to persons performing platform work who are also business users as defined in Article 2, point (1), of Regulation (EU) 2019/1150.

Article 1(2) states that the Directive provides measures on algorithmic management applicable to persons performing platform work in the Union, including those who do not have an employment contract or employment relationship. Article 2(1), point (c), defines a person performing platform work as an individual performing platform work, irrespective of the nature of the contractual relationship or the designation of that relationship by the parties involved.

Article 2(1), point (a), defines a digital labour platform as a natural or legal person providing a service that is provided, at least in part, at a distance by electronic means, at the request of a recipient of the service, that involves the organisation of work performed by individuals in return for payment as a necessary and essential component, and that involves the use of automated monitoring systems or automated decision-making systems.

Article 1(3) applies the Directive to digital labour platforms organising platform work performed in the Union, irrespective of their place of establishment or of the law otherwise applicable.

Article 24(1) makes the supervisory authorities responsible for monitoring the application of Regulation (EU) 2016/679 also responsible for monitoring and enforcing Articles 7 to 11 as far as data-protection matters are concerned, and applies the upper limit for administrative fines referred to in Article 83(5) of that Regulation to infringements of Articles 7 to 11.

Article 24(5) requires Member States to lay down the rules on penalties applicable to infringements of the national provisions adopted pursuant to the Directive, and the penalties must be effective, dissuasive and proportionate to the nature, gravity and duration of the undertaking's infringement and to the number of workers affected.

Article 29(1) requires Member States to bring into force the laws, regulations and administrative provisions necessary to comply with the Directive by .

When LexLint raises it

When your app profile says your app makes high-risk automated decisions.

Back to the example  ·  Lint your app