Law / Canada / Ontario

Personal Health Information Protection Act, 2004, offences and damages for breach of privacy

S.O. 2004, c. 3, Sched. A, ss. 65, 72

In force since .

An enforcement supervision rule binding public and private bodies.

Obligation class
Prohibition, Governance
Audit expectation
none

What it requires

  • These offences reach any person, including a custodian, an agent, a supplier to a custodian and a person who holds a health number or de-identified information.
  • Do not wilfully collect, use or disclose personal health information in contravention of the Act or its regulations, and do not wilfully dispose of a record in contravention of the secure disposal duty.NIST Privacy FrameworkCT.PO-P1NIST Privacy FrameworkCT.DM-P5
  • Do not contravene the health number rules in section 34 (2), (3) or (4), and do not wilfully use de-identified information to identify an individual.NIST Privacy FrameworkCT.PO-P1
  • Do not make a request for access to or correction of a record of personal health information under false pretences, do not dispose of a record of personal health information in the custody or under the control of the prescribed organization with an intent to evade a request for access to it, and do not wilfully obstruct or mislead the Commissioner or fail to comply with the Commissioner's order.

These lines are LexLint's reading of the law's text. Also read by: Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario (guidance, recorded ); Hopkins v. Kay, 2015 ONCA 112 (recorded ).

In the frameworks

NIST Privacy Framework
  • CT.PO-P1Policies, processes, and procedures for authorizing data processing (e.g., organizational decisions, individual consent), revoking authorizations, and maintaining authorizations are established and in place.
  • CT.DM-P5Data are destroyed according to policy.
NIST CSF 2.0
  • ID.AM-08Systems, hardware, software, services, and data are managed throughout their life cycles
FINOS AIGF

Our reading of where this law's duties sit in each framework, and in the NIST Privacy Framework, line by line beside each duty above. It never says that running a control meets the law. How we read a framework against the law

If you get it wrong

Criminal exposureYes

Private right of actionYes

Criminal exposure note

Subsection 72 (1) lists the offences, among them wilfully collecting, using or disclosing personal health information in contravention of the Act, and subsection 72 (2) sets the penalty for a natural person at a fine of not more than $200,000 or imprisonment for not more than one year, or both.

Penalty structure

Section 72 (2) sets a fine of not more than $1,000,000 for a person that is not a natural person, and for a natural person a fine of not more than $200,000 or imprisonment for not more than one year, or both.

Rule
Fixed only
As of
Currency
CAD
Fixed cap
1,000,000

Who enforces it

Enforcement body

Attorney General of Ontario, whose consent a prosecution requires

Settledness

As of
Case link
https://web.archive.org/web/20150707215954/http://www.ontariocourts.ca/decisions/2015/2015ONCA0112.htm
Guidance link
https://www.ipc.on.ca/en/health-organizations/responding-to-a-privacy-breach/potential-consequences-of-a-breach-under-phipa
Case citation
Hopkins v. Kay, 2015 ONCA 112
Guidance body
Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario
Open questions
  • Does 'a person affected by the order' in section 65 (1) reach an individual whose record was accessed but who was not a party to the Commissioner's review that produced the order?
  • Does 'actual harm' in section 65 (1) include mental anguish when the court finds no wilful or reckless contravention under section 65 (3)?

What record it asks for

Logging duty

Sections 65 and 72 provide damages for a breach of privacy and offences. They state no log or record duty. Section 72 (1) (e) makes it an offence to dispose wilfully of a record of personal health information in contravention of s. 13, which protects the information and is outside the cited range.

Kind
None
As of

What this law does

Drafted with AI

Drafted with AI from the cited sources under the direction of UnGovr staff. UnGovr holds editorial responsibility for this page. How this site is made

Research summary

Legal information, not legal advice. This is LexLint's own research summary of a public legal source, and it creates no attorney-client relationship. For decisions that matter, consult qualified counsel in the relevant jurisdiction. About LexLint

A person is guilty of an offence if the person wilfully collects, uses or discloses personal health information in contravention of the Act or its regulations.

The offences also include contravening the health number rules in subsection 34 (2), (3) or (4), wilfully contravening the limit on using de-identified information to identify an individual, wilfully disposing of a record in contravention of the secure disposal duty, disposing of a record of personal health information in the custody or under the control of the prescribed organization with an intent to evade a request for access to the record, wilfully failing to comply with an order of the Commissioner, and making a request under the Act for access to or correction of a record under false pretences.

A person who is a natural person and is convicted is liable to a fine of not more than $200,000 or to imprisonment for not more than one year, or to both, and a person that is not a natural person is liable to a fine of not more than $1,000,000. An officer, member, employee or other agent of a corporation who authorized the offence, or who had the authority to prevent it and knowingly refrained from doing so, is a party to and guilty of the offence.

A prosecution may not be commenced without the consent of the Attorney General or the Attorney General's agent. The penalties in subsection 72 (2) are as amended by chapter 5 of the Statutes of Ontario, 2020, in force from . If the Commissioner has made an order that has become final, a person affected by the order may commence a proceeding in the Superior Court of Justice for damages for actual harm suffered as a result of a contravention of the Act or its regulations.

A person affected by the conduct that gave rise to an offence of which a person has been convicted may commence a proceeding for damages for actual harm once the conviction has become final. If the harm was caused by a contravention or offence that the defendants engaged in wilfully or recklessly, the court may include in its award of damages an award, not exceeding $10,000, for mental anguish.

When LexLint raises it

When your app profile says your app handles health records or processes personal data.

Back to the example  ·  Lint your app

Page updated .